SELF-DETERMINATION AND TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY REVISITED: REFLECTING CHAGOS ADVISORY OPINION AND ITS COMPARISON WITH WEST PAPUA

Irfan Fadilah, Parusa Seno Adirespati


DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17304/ijil.vol17.1.778

Abstract


The right to self-determination and territorial integrity are amongst the cardinal principles of international law mostly utilised in determining the territory of a state. Both principles are equally protected and guaranteed under international law, and any attempt for total or partial disruption of a territory violates the right to self-determination of peoples. The relation between the two principles is evident in Chagos Advisory Opinion issued by ICJ which states that a former colonial territory detached by a colonial power violates the right to self-determination unless such detachment is based on freely expressed will of the people of the concerned territory. The Chagos Archipelago was originally detached from Mauritius by the UK prior to its independence in 1968. A similar situation was also apparent in Western Papua, in which the Dutch administration attempted to detach it from Indonesia prior to the transfer of sovereignty in 1949 under the name of Dutch Western New Guinea. This attempted detachment became one of the biggest arguments used in supporting Papuan independence since it was narrated that the territories were under a different administration. This article argues that such detachment is considered a disruption of territorial unity, which ultimately violates the right to self-determination of people. Furthermore, it also argues on how Indonesia has sovereignty over Western Papua. Those issues will also be discussed through the lens of international politics, especially in terms of the existence of state interests, both related to the former colonial countries and the international community in addressing the two cases.


Keywords


uti possidetis juris; decolonization; detachment of colonial territories; Chagos Advisory Opinion; the right to self-determination; territorial integrity; West Papua

References


Legal documents

United Kingdom. British Indian Ocean Territory Order 1965. Statutory Instrument No. 1920 of 1965.

_______. Foreign and Commonwealth Office. United Kingdom, Mauritius and Diego Garcia: The Question of Consent- Note from 28 August 1965. FCO 31/3437.

An Arbitration before an arbitral tribunal constituted under Annex VII of the United Nations Convention on Law of the Sea (Mauritius v. UK). [2015]. ICGJ 486 (PCA 2015).

Charter of the Transfer of Sovereignty between the Kingdom of the Netherlands and the Republic of the United States of Indonesia, 1949.

Charter of the United Nations. (opened for signature 26 June 1945, entered into force 24 October 1945).

Commission of Rapporteur. The Aland Island Question. League of Nations Doc. B7. 21/68/106. 16 April 1921.

Cristescu, Aureliu. The Right to Self-Determination: Historic and Current Development on the Basis of United Nations Instruments. UN Doc. E/CN.4/Sub.2/404/Rev.1.

General Assembly resolution 66(I). Transmission of Information under Article 73e of the Charter. A/RES/66(I) (14 December 1946). Available from: https://undocs.org/en/A/RES/66(I) (accessed 11 May 2020).

General Assembly resolution 1514. Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples. A/RES/1514(XV) (14 December 1960). Available from https://undocs.org/en/A/RES/1514(XV) (accessed 13 August 2019).

General Assembly resolution 71/292. Request for an advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice on the legal consequences of the separation of the Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius in 1965. A/RES/71/292 (22 June 2017). Available from https://undocs.org/en/A/RES/71/292 (accessed 13 August 2019).

International Court of Justice. Temple of Preah Vihear (Cambodia v. Thailand). Judgement. [1962]. ICJ Reports 1962.

_______. North Sea Continental Shelf (UK v. Norway). Judgement. [1969]. ICJ Reports 1969.

_______. Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) Notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276. Advisory Opinion. [1971]. ICJ Reports 1971.

_______. Western Sahara. Advisory Opinion. [1975]. ICJ Reports 1975.

_______. Continental Shelf (Tunisia v. Libyan Arab Jamahirriya). Judgement. [1982]. ICJ Reports 1982.

_______. Frontier Dispute (Burkina Faso v. Mali). Judgement. [1986]. ICJ Reports 1986.

_______. Land, Island, and Maritime Frontier Dispute (Salvador v. Honduras). Judgement. [1992]. ICJ Reports 1992.

_______. East Timor (Australia v. Portugal). Judgement. [1995]. ICJ Reports 1995.

_______. Legal Consequences of The Separation of The Chagos Archipelago from Mauritius in 1965. Advisory Opinion. [2019]. ICJ Reports 2019.

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. 999 UNTS 171, 1057 UNTS 407 (opened for signature 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976).

R v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs, ex parte Bancoult (No. 2), [2008], UKHL 61.

The Question of West Irian (West New Guinea). United Nations Doc. A/2694. 18 August 1954.

United Nations Commission for Indonesia. “Special Report to the Security Council on the Round Table Conference.” 10 November 1949, S/1417.

United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO). International Meeting of Experts for the Elucidation of the Concepts of Rights of Peoples. SHS89/CONF.602/7. 22 February 1990.

United Nations General Assembly. 15th Session. 947th Plenary Meeting. A/P.V.947.

_______. 15th Session. 936th Plenary Meeting. A/PV.936.

Books and book chapters

Allen, Stephen, and Chris Monaghan. Fifty Years of the British Indian Ocean Territory. Springer International, 2018.

Blackburn, Susan. Jakarta: Sejarah 400 Tahun [Jakarta: A History]. Translated by Gatot Triwira. Komunitas Bambu, 2011.

Drakeley, Steven. The History of Indonesia. Greenwood Press, 2005.

El Ouali, Abdelhamid. Territorial Integrity in a Globalizing World: International Law and Quests for States’ Survival. Springfield Verlag Heidelberg, 2012.

Fisch, Jörg. The Right of Self-Determination of Peoples: The Domestication of an Illusion. Cambridge University Press, 2015.

Franck, Thomas M. Nation Against Nation: What Happened to the UN Dream and What the US Can Do About It. Oxford University Press, 1985.

Jennings, Ivor. The Approach to Self-Government. Cambridge Publishing, 1956.

Jennings, Robert Yewdall. The Acquisition of Territory in International Law. Manchester University Press, 1963.

Kusuma, RM. A. B. Lahirnya Undang-undang Dasar 1945 [The Birth of 1945 Indonesian Constitution]. Badan Penerbit Fakultas Hukum Universitas Indonesia, 2016.

Raic, David. Statehood and the Law of Self-Determination. Kluwer Law International, 2002.

Rodriguez-Santiago, Elizabeth. “The Evolution of Self-Determination of Peoples in International Law”. In The Theory of Self-Determination edited by Teson, Fernando R. Cambridge University Press, 2016.

Rothermund, Dietmar. Routledge Companions to Decolonization. Routledge, 2009.

Shaw, Malcolm N. International Law. Cambridge University Press, 2008.

Taylor, Jean Gelman. Indonesia: Peoples and Histories. Yale University Press, 2003.

Trinidad, Jamie. Self-Determination in Disputed Colonial Territories. Cambridge University Press. 2018.

van der Vossen, Bas. “Self-Determination and Moral Variation.” In The Theory of Self-Determination edited by Teson, Fernando R. Cambridge University Press. 2016.

Wellman, Christopher Heath. A Theory of Secession. Cambridge University Press, 2005.

Wibawa, Samodra. Negara-negara di Nusantara: Dari Negara-Kota hingga Negara-Bangsa, dari Modernisasi hingga Reformasi Administrasi [States in Nusantara: From the City-states to Nation-states from Modernisation to Administrative Reform]. Gadjah Mada University Press, 2001.

Tomuschat, Christian. “Yugoslavia’s Damaged Sovereignty over the Province of Kosovo”. In Kreijen, Gerrard, et al. State, Sovereignty, and International Governance. Oxford University Press. 2002.

Journal and periodicals

Blay, S.K.N. “Self-Determination versus Territorial Integrity in Decolonization.” New York University Journal of International Law and Politics (1986): 863-880.

Bogdanor, Vernon. “Ethnic Nationalism in Western Europe.” Journal of Political Studies 30, no. 2 (1982): 284-291.

Corten, Oliver. “Territorial Integrity Narrowly Interpreted: Reasserting the Classical Inter-State Paradigm of International Law.” Leiden Journal of International Law 24 (2011): 87-94.

Kadir, M. Yakub Ayyub. “Application of The Law of Self-Determination in The Post-Colonial Context: A Guideline”. Journal of East Asia and International Law 9, no. 1 (2016).

Koskenniemi, Martti. “National Self-Determination Today: Problems of Legal Theory and Practice.” International Comparative Law Quarterly 43, no. 2. (1994): 241-269.

Ratner, Steven B. “Drawing a Better Line: Uti Possidetis and the Borders of New States.” American Journal of International Law 90, no. 4 (1996): 590-624

Robertson, Geoffrey. “Who Owns Diego Garcia? Decolonisation and Indigenous Rights in the Indian Ocean.” University of Western Australia Law Review 3, no. 1 (2012).

Shaw, Malcolm N. “The Heritage of States: The Principle of Uti Possidetis Today.” British Yearbook of International Law (1997): 75-154.

Summers, James. “Decolonisation revisited and the obligation not to divide a Non-Self-Governing Territory.” QIL, Zoom-out 55 (2018): 147-176.

Web sources

Breese, Evie. “West Papua - Whose history?”. Accessed on 16 August 2019. https://southeastasiaglobe.com/fifty-years-on-pasts-collide-in-indonesia-and-papua/.

Cribb, Robert. “Digital Atlas of Indonesian History: Chapter 4: The Netherlands Indies, 1800 – 1942”. Accessed on 1 September 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20180206204720/http://www.indonesianhistory.info/pages/chapter-4.html.

Davidson, Helen. “West Papuan independence group says it is ‘ready to take over country’”. Accessed on 1 September 2019. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jul/03/west-papuan-independence-group-say-they-are-ready-to-take-over-country.

Tehusijarana, Karina M. “Papua mass killing: What happened”. Accessed on 13 August 2019. https://wwwthejakartapost.com/news/2018/12/07/papua-mass-killing-what-happened.html.




Creative Commons License
Indonesian Journal of International Law is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.